Economy
Highlights The rising policy rate in the past couple months has been driven by a liquidity crunch, which is expected to ease in Q4. Government bond yields, which have been trending upwards since May, will also take a breather. The extremely accommodative phase of monetary conditions has ended. Monetary policy will be tightened, possibly by the middle of next year. We expect the yield curve to move broadly sideways in Q4 and into early 2021. As early as Q2 next year, a rebound in rate hike expectations will cause the curve to flatten. We remain overweight on Chinese stocks over the next six to nine months. Beyond that, a more restrictive monetary policy and less buoyant economic outlook may warrant a trimming of positions in Chinese stocks. Feature Chinese government bond yields have rebounded sharply since bottoming in late April; 10-year yields have climbed by 62 basis points to 3.1% as we go to press. Given that the 3-month SHIBOR (the PBoC’s de facto policy rate) has gone up by 128 basis points from its nadir in April, the higher bond yields reflect policy-driven liquidity tightening. The economy’s quick turnaround following the reopening of business activities has prompted the authorities to normalize the monetary stance (Chart 1). China recently made more interbank liquidity injections to slow the speed of policy rate normalization. We think it is the right move. China’s economic recovery is still at an early stage and may not withstand a rapid tightening in monetary policy. Furthermore, the chances are low that the 3-month SHIBOR will rise above its pre-COVID-19 level of 3% in this calendar year. Yields on short-duration government bonds will have little room to move higher in 2020. China’s 10-year government bond yield may even drop slightly when geopolitical tensions between the US and China heat up as the US election nears. Chart 1Policy Rate Normalization Started In May Chart 2Rate Normalization Will Resume In 2021 As China’s economic recovery is expected to continue accelerating into the first half of 2021, interest rates will also resume their climb (Chart 2). Our base case view is that the first rate hike, which will lift the policy rate above its pre-COVID-19 level, will happen as early as Q2 next year but no later than mid-2021. This means that the cyclical bear market in the bond market will continue. A Temporary Easing In Q4… In our report published on February 19, we argued that the rally in Chinese government bonds in early 2020 would be short lived rather than a cyclical (6-12 month) play.1 Furthermore, a journey back to the pre-outbreak monetary stance would start as early as Q2 this year. Notably, Chinese policymakers have pivoted to normalize monetary policy from an ultra-loose stance linked to COVID-19. In our view, the speed of the rebound in the policy rate has run ahead of the economic recovery. In other words, the policy stance tightened before inflation expectations turned more optimistic (Chart 3). Retail sales growth barely turned positive in August from a year ago, core inflation has dropped to its lowest level since the Global Financial Crisis and producer prices are still contracting on an annual basis (Chart 4). Chart 3Policy Stance Tightened Before Inflation Moved Higher In the past two weeks, the PBoC has injected liquidity more frequently through open market operations, an indication that policymakers may be trying to slow the pace of tightening (Chart 5). Maintaining nominal GDP growth above 4% this year is politically imperative for the Communist Party to achieve its employment growth objective.2 This overarching goal will likely hold back the PBoC from easing off the gas too abruptly. Chart 4The Economy Is Still Growing Below The Trend Growth Liquidity conditions will continue to improve into Q4, moderating the rise in the 3-month SHIBOR. The liquidity crunch in the banking system since May was created by a massive government bond issuance and curbing of high-yield structured deposits. Government bond issuance has reached its peak this year and bond quotas will plummet in Q4, which will help ease liquidity shortages in the banking sector (Chart 6). In turn, demand for interbank liquidity should moderate as banks have fewer bond purchasing obligations, giving the 3-month SHIBOR some breathing room with or without the PBoC’s intervention. Chart 5The PBoC May Be Trying To Slow The Pace Of Its Rate Normalization A pause in the policy rate hike will limit any upside risks for yields on short-duration government bonds. Yields on 10-year bonds may even drop if tensions between the US and China escalate leading up to the November US election, and/or additional significant pandemic waves affect the global economy. Chart 6Liquidity Conditions Should Ease In Q4 Bottom Line: It is unlikely that China’s policy rate and the long-duration government bond yield will end the year above their pre-COVID-19 levels. …Followed By Decisive Rate Hikes In 2H21 There are good and rising odds that Chinese authorities will fully switch to a tightening mode in 2021. Barring any domestic resurgence in COVID-19 that could trigger lockdowns, the PBoC may resume policy rate hikes as early as Q2, and no later than mid-2021. Our reasoning is as follows: Chart 7The PBoC Has Been Consistent With Policy Reaction In Previous Recoveries Consistent policy reaction in previous recoveries. Our April 23 report showed how the PBoC has been consistent in normalizing its monetary policy following each of the past three economic and credit cycles.3 The central bank raised interest rates on average nine months following a bottom in the business cycle. The tightening of interest rates occurred even after the prolonged economic downturn and deep deflationary cycle in 2015/16. The structurally slowing rate of China’s economic growth since 2011 has not prevented the PBoC from cyclically raising its policy rate (Chart 7). When the output gap is closed in 1H21, the PBoC will gain enough confidence to push for higher interest rates. Property market is strong. The property market has been heating up on the back of falling bank lending rates, despite policymakers’ efforts to curb both property lending and purchases. New home sales surged by 40% in August, the highest year-over-year growth since the last housing boom in 2016. In particular, demand for the first- and second-tier cities have rebounded sharply (Chart 8). This trend will likely prompt policymakers to enact stronger and earlier policy responses by tightening the medium lending facility (MLF) rate, an anchor for the mortgage lending rate. The labor market is recovering. The employment sub-indexes in the official PMIs of late point to an improvement in both the manufacturing and non-manufacturing sectors (Chart 9). Additionally, by the end of June, the number of returned migrant workers reached 96% of last year’s level. At this rate, the labor market should return to its pre-COVID-19 level by early next year. Chart 8Property Market Is Heating Up Chart 9The Labor Market Is Recovering Inflation will probably accelerate next year. We expect the recovery in the labor market to drive up both wage income and core CPI next year. Higher oil and industrial metals prices should also lift producer prices (Chart 10). Higher interest rates may not be counterproductive to policymakers’ support for SMEs. This is due to the authorities’ “window guidance”, mandating banks to reduce the spread between the loan prime rate (LPR) and bank lending rates. As seen in the past five months, although the policy rate has been rising, average bank lending rates have fallen (Chart 11). Policymakers will likely continue hiking policy rate to curb financial and property market speculations, but at the same time still able to guide bank lending rates lower and target their support for SMEs. Chart 10Inflation Will Likely Accelerate Along With Economic Growth In 1H21 Chart 11Bank Lending Rates Have Been Trending Down Despite Rising Policy Rate Bottom Line: Odds are rising that the PBoC will continue to hike interest rates (short and medium-term) by the middle of next year. In turn, the rebound in Chinese government bond yields will resume early next year in the expectation of better economic conditions and policy tightening. Investment Conclusions The upward momentum in both the short and long-end of the yield curve will likely abate from now till year-end (Chart 12, top panel). As early as Q2 next year, however, a rebound in rate hike expectations will cause the curve to flatten. Historically, the yield curve has always moved in lockstep with the 3-month SHIBOR with a perfect reverse correlation (Chart 12, bottom panel). Given the extremely dovish stance among central banks (the Fed in particular), the upside in rate hikes by PBoC will be capped. We expect a less than 30bps rise in long-term bond yields. Tighter monetary policy is bullish for the RMB. Nonetheless, the risk-return profile of taking a direct bet on the RMB is not attractive in either direction. The CNY has appreciated against the USD by 5% since bottoming in May, and we doubt that there will be a meaningful upside in the RMB against the dollar leading up to the US election. Meanwhile, widening interest-rate differentials have further reduced the odds of any significant CNY/USD depreciation (Chart 13). Chart 12A Rebound In Rate Hike Expectations In 1H21 Will Flatten The Yield Curve Chart 13Limited Upside For The RMB Against USD And On Trade-Weighted Basis In this vein, the CNY/USD exchange rate will be dominated by broader dollar performance. Furthermore, it is highly unlikely that the PBoC will tolerate sharp, trade-weighted currency appreciations. A declining USD will also limit the upside in the trade-weighted RMB. The RMB may be less reflationary to businesses in China, but it will not become outright deflationary for the time being (Chart 13, middle and bottom panels). In terms of equities, we maintain our positive cyclical view on China's growth outlook. The PBoC will maintain its tightening bias, but this should not lead to major growth disappointments. We continue to expect Chinese domestic and investable equities to outperform in both absolute and relative terms, at least for the next six to nine months. Beyond the next six months, however, a more restrictive monetary policy should bring China’s economy closer to its trend growth in 2H21. Sectors such as technology and real estate, which benefit the most from easy liquidity conditions and strong economic growth, will be negatively and disproportionally impacted. Given their heavy weight in China’s investable equity market, we will probably trim our positions in investable stocks by the middle of next year. Jing Sima China Strategist jings@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see BCA Research China Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Don’t Chase China’s Bond Yields Lower", dated February 19, 2020, available at cis.bcareseach.com. 2 Please see BCA Research China Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Taking The Pulse Of The People’s Congress", dated May 28, 2020, available at cis.bcareseach.com. 3 Please see BCA Research China Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Three Questions Following The Coronacrisis", dated April 23, 2020, available at cis.bcareseach.com. Cyclical Investment Stance Equity Sector Recommendations
Highlights Bank credit 6-month impulses are plunging, and the pandemic is resurging. Maintain an overweight to growth defensives (technology and healthcare). In the short term, profits will be more resilient in a resurgent pandemic. In the long term, profits are well set to grow in an increasingly online, decentralised, remote-working, health-conscious world. The European stock market’s massive underweighting to growth defensives will weigh on its relative performance. Go underweight China economy plays. Fractal trade: Fractal analysis confirms that basic resources are vulnerable to a reversal. Within value cyclicals, tactically overweight financials versus basic resources. Feature Chart of the WeekThe Greatest Ever Monetary Stimulus Is Over... For Now Monetary stimulus, as measured by the increase in banks’ six-month credit flows, reached an all-time high during the summer months. But now, the greatest ever monetary stimulus is fading (Chart of the Week). In the US and China, the increase in banks’ six-month credit flows peaked at $700 billion and $800 billion respectively during May. In the euro area, the increase peaked at over $1 trillion during July. The combination constituted the greatest ever global monetary stimulus, trumping even the stimulus that followed the 2008 financial crisis (Charts I-2 - I-4). Chart I-2US Monetary Stimulus Is Fading Chart I-3China Monetary Stimulus Is Fading Chart I-4Euro Area Monetary Stimulus To Fade However, the increase in six-month credit flows has recently slumped to around $200 billion in both the US and China. The euro area has yet to update its data beyond July, but we expect it to fade too. The upshot is that the greatest ever monetary stimulus is over… for now. Bond Yields Are No Longer Stimulating Our preferred metric for assessing the transmission of monetary stimulus on an economy is the increase in the banks’ six-month credit flows. In turn, this depends on the six-month deceleration in the bond yield – meaning, the bond yield decline in the most recent six months must be greater than the decline in the previous six months. At first glance, this seems counterintuitive. Why focus on the bond yield’s deceleration rather than its plain vanilla decline? Box 1 explains how it follows from a fundamental accounting identity of GDP statistics. Box 1 Why The Bond Yield’s Deceleration Matters GDP is a flow statistic. It measures the flow of goods and services produced in a period. Hence, the GDP flow receives a contribution from the bank credit flow in that period. In turn, the bank credit flow is established by the decline in the bond yield (Chart I-5). Chart I-5The Decline In The Bond Yield Establishes The Bank Credit Flow It follows that GDP growth receives a contribution from bank credit flow growth. Which, in turn, receives a contribution from the bond yield deceleration. In other words, the bond yield decline in the most recent period must be greater than the decline in the previous period. Finally, our preferred period is six months because it empirically equals the time to fully spend a bank credit flow. A quarter is too short: a year is much too long. Admittedly, during this year’s pandemic recession and rebound, the link between monetary stimulus and the real economy has weakened. Fiscal stimulus has played a more important role. Even when it comes to bank credit, much of the recent increase was not due to new loans. It was due to firms tapping pre-arranged credit lines, which they used to reinforce cash buffers, rather than to spend. Nevertheless, some impact of monetary stimulus will reach the real economy. This means that while this year’s earlier deceleration of bond yields was good news for the economy, the more recent acceleration of bond yields is bad news (Chart I-6). Chart I-6The Recent Acceleration Of Bond Yields Is Bad News Tactically Underweight China Plays Through the summer months, 10-year bond yields flipped from sharp six-month decelerations to sharp accelerations. But the reversals were much more extreme in China and the US than in the euro area. Seen in this light, it is hardly surprising that the increase in six-month bank credit flows has already slumped in China and the US, and could soon turn negative. If so, they would be a contractionary force on the economy. One tactical investment conclusion is to underweight China economy plays. Specifically, with China’s bank credit six-month impulse in freefall, the 40 percent outperformance of basic resources versus financials is vulnerable to a sharp reversal (Chart I-7). This is also confirmed by fractal analysis (see later section). Chart I-7With China's Bank Credit 6-Month Impulse In Freefall, Basic Resources Are Vulnerable Stay underweight cyclicals. But within cyclicals, tactically overweight financials versus basic resources. A Resurgent Pandemic Will Force People Back Into Their Shells A resurgence of the pandemic will create a further headwind to the economy, irrespective of whether governments impose fresh lockdowns or not. This is because most of us have an instinct for self-preservation as well as protecting our loved ones. In response to a resurgent pandemic, we will go back into our shells. Shunning public transport, shopping, and other crowded places, some might even think twice about letting their children go to school. But if this cautious behaviour is voluntary, then why do governments need to impose lockdowns? The answer is that while the majority behaves responsibly, a minority behaves irresponsibly. In the pandemic, this is critical because less than 10 percent of infected people are responsible for creating 90 percent of all Covid-19 infections. If this tiny minority of so-called ‘super-spreaders’ is left unchecked, then the pandemic will let rip. At first glance, it appears that the lockdown is causing the recession. In fact, this is a classic confusion between correlation and causation. The true cause of the recession is the pandemic, which forces people into their shells. But to the extent that severity of the lockdown correlates with the severity of the pandemic, many people confuse the correlated lockdown with the underlying cause, the pandemic. The ultimate proof comes from Scandinavia. Sweden imposed no lockdown, while its neighbour Denmark imposed the most extreme lockdown in Europe. If it was the lockdown that caused the recession, then the economy of no-lockdown Sweden should have fared much better than that of lockdown Denmark. In fact, the two Scandinavian economies suffered identical 9 percent recessions (Chart I-8). Chart I-8No-Lockdown Sweden Suffered An Identical Recession To Lockdown-Denmark Focus On Sectors That Can Thrive In The New World Tactically we have recommended an underweight to stocks versus bonds since July 9, and this tactical position is broadly flat. Stick with it for now.1 A crucial question is: can bond yields go significantly lower? It is a crucial question because it was the collapse in bond yields earlier this year that saved the aggregate stock market. As long-duration bond yields plunged by 1 percent, the forward earnings yield of long-duration technology and healthcare stocks also plunged by 1 percent (Chart I-9). This surge in the valuation of the growth defensive sectors compensated for the collapsed profits of the value cyclical sectors – banks, basic resources, and oil and gas (Chart I-10). A resurgent pandemic combined with the end of the greatest ever monetary stimulus means that this playbook may get a rerun in the coming months. Chart I-9The Collapsed Bond Yield Explains The Collapsed Earnings Yield (Surging Valuation) Of Tech And Healthcare Chart I-10Tech And Healthcare Saved The Aggregate Stock Market The worry is that, from current levels, long-duration bond yields will struggle to plunge by another 1 percent and provide the same boost to valuations that they did in the first wave of the pandemic. In which case, the outlook for stocks and sectors will hinge more on their profits. On this basis, we still favour the growth defensives – which we define as technology and healthcare – both for the short term and the long term. In the short term, their profits will be more resilient in a resurgent pandemic. In the long term, their profits are well set to grow in an increasingly online, decentralised, remote-working, health-conscious world. One unfortunate consequence is that the European stock market’s massive underweighting to the growth defensives sectors will weigh on its relative performance, both in the short term and in the long term. Fractal Trading System* Supporting the fundamental analysis in the main body of this report, fractal analysis confirms that basic resources are vulnerable to a reversal versus financials. Hence, this week’s recommended trade is to go long financials versus basic resources. One way of implementing this is: long XLF, short XLB. Set the profit target and symmetrical stop-loss at 3.5 percent. In other trades, long ZAR/CLP reached the end of its holding period flat, and is now closed. The rolling 1-year win ratio now stands at 58 percent. When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Expressed as short DAX versus 10-year T-bond. Fractal Trading System Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
Highlights Bond Yields & Growth: Developed market bond yields have ignored improving cyclical economic data over the past few months, remaining stuck in narrow trading ranges at low levels. That broken correlation will persist until central banks become less concerned about supporting pandemic-ravaged economies and begin worrying more about rising inflation, financial stability or the size of their balance sheets. That shift will not happen anytime soon. Inflation-Linked Trades: Our models suggest US TIPS breakevens are now at fair value. We are taking profits on our tactical long US 10-year inflation breakevens trade for a return of 2.88%. Stay long 10-year breakevens in Italy and Canada until we see further shrinkage in the gap between inflation breakevens and model-implied fair value and watch for a selling opportunity in UK 10-year breakevens. Feature Do bond investors even care about economic growth anymore? This is a valid question to ask, given how government bond yields in the developed markets have stayed in very narrow trading ranges over the past few months, even as economic data has rebounded from the global COVID-19 recession in the first half of 2020. Investors should get used to the current backdrop of rock-bottom interest rates and bond yields, which is unlikely to change anytime soon. Chart of the WeekBond Yields Are Responding To Inflation, Not Growth For example, the benchmark 10-year US Treasury yield has stayed between 0.65% and 0.75% since June 11, even though the US ISM Manufacturing index rose from 43 in May to 56 in August. Yields are also ignoring the ups and downs of the equity market. The 10-year Treasury yield now sits at 0.66% - the same level as on September 2 even though the NASDAQ equity index has fallen 12% from the all-time peak seen on that day. Our own Global Duration Indicator, comprised of cyclical measures like the global ZEW index and our global leading economic indicator, has surged to the highest level since 2008 (Chart of the Week). Given the usual lead time between broad turns in the Duration Indicator and the level of global bond yields (around 6-9 months), this suggests that yields have bottomed and should soon begin rising. Yet the reality is that the usual factors that typically drive yields higher during a cyclical upturn – namely, rising inflation expectations and a clearly understood signal from central banks that such a move would lead to tighter monetary policy – are not currently in place. Investors should get used to the current backdrop of rock-bottom interest rates and bond yields, which is unlikely to change anytime soon. Four Potential Triggers For A Rise In Bond Yields Chart 2A Breakdown Of The PMI/Yield correlation The breakdown of the positive correlation between growth and bond yields is not just visible in the US. For example, yields on German Bunds and UK Gilts also remain stuck at low levels despite sharp improvements in the German and UK manufacturing PMIs (Chart 2). Yet in China – where there is no zero interest rate policy (ZIRP) or large-scale quantitative easing (QE) programs - bond yields have steadily risen since the China manufacturing PMI bottomed back in April (bottom panel). What could change this backdrop? We see four potential catalysts, ranked below in our own subjective order of importance: Inflation Sustainably Returning Back To Central Bank Targets It may seem obvious, but it still needs to be said – dovish central bank policies are the biggest reason why developed market bond yields have de-linked from economic growth. That includes not only ZIRP or QE, but also forward guidance on future changes in interest rates. Central banks are telling markets they will not raise rates for a period measured in years, and will continue to expand their balance sheets to purchase assets and support bank lending, all in an effort to push undershooting inflation back to policy targets. This is a different message than bond investors have grown accustomed to hearing from central banks, most notably in the US. The Fed is trying to do something that it has never intentionally done before – erode some of its hard-earned inflation fighting credibility. The Fed is trying to do something that it has never intentionally done before – erode some of its hard-earned inflation fighting credibility. The recent shift by the Fed to an Average Inflation Targeting framework – where above-target inflation would be tolerated if inflation was below target for an extended period – is intended to change the perception that the Fed will hike rates preemptively based on a forecast of inflation, as they have done in the past. Chart 3Latest FOMC Projections Justify Years Of 0% Rates The latest set of Fed economic projections is consistent with this new framework (Chart 3): the unemployment rate is forecasted to fall back to the FOMC median estimate of full employment (4.1%) by 2023; headline PCE inflation is also projected to climb back to 2% by 2023; the fed funds rate is projected to stay unchanged near 0% until at least 2023. In many ways, the Fed is trying to atone for the mistakes made while normalizing policy after the extraordinary easing measures taken after the 2008 crisis. From signaling a slowing of QE bond purchases in 2013, to the 250bps of rate hikes and tapering of its balance sheet during 2016-18, the Fed moved aggressively relative to what was actually happening with US inflation. Core PCE inflation only inched above 2% for a few months in 2018 – towards the end of the normalization process - as did market-based inflation measures like TIPS breakevens (Chart 4). The Fed ended up raising the real fed funds rate during that tightening cycle to above its own estimate of neutral (r-star), even with inflation still not close to its target. Unsurprisingly, real US bond yields also rose during that same period, which tightened monetary conditions even further by boosting the value of the US dollar. No wonder US inflation could not stay at the 2% target for very long. This time around, the Fed is sending a much different signal to markets – that it wants to see inflation rise before raising rates, thus keeping real policy rates in negative territory for an extended period. If the Fed is looking for a real world case study of such an approach, it can look across the Atlantic to the Bank of England (BoE). On the surface, the BoE has been acting like a typical inflation-targeting central bank over the past several years, turning more hawkish in its commentary when the UK economy was improving and becoming more dovish when the economy was languishing. Yet since the 2008 crisis, the BoE has kept the Bank Rate in a range of 0.1% to 0.75%, well below realized UK inflation. While it has been difficult for the BoE to attempt to raise rates given the Brexit uncertainty since 2016 – which has also weakened the British pound, helping boost UK inflation - real UK policy rates have now been negative for 12 years (Chart 5). The result: steadily declining UK real bond yields with inflation expectations rising to levels well above the BoE 2% inflation target. Chart 4The Fed Is Trying To Erode Its Hard-Earned Credibility Chart 5Lessons From The BoE On How To Not Be Credible The experience of the ECB provides a cautionary tale for central banks not appearing dovish enough, even when policy settings are already extraordinarily accommodative. The message from central banks on future rate increases – namely, that there will not be any without sustainably higher inflation – must change before bond yields can have any hope of climbing higher. Chart 6Does The ECB Have Any Credibility Left? Inflation expectations have stayed below the ECB’s “just below 2%” target since 2013 (Chart 6), which forced the central bank into cutting nominal rates into negative territory while aggressively expanding its balance sheet through QE and long-term bank liquidity provision (i.e. LTROs). Yet the ECB has always put an expiration date on each of these programs, which sent a message to the markets that the central bank was not fully committed to keeping policy easy until inflation was back to target – however long that would take. In sum, the message from central banks on future rate increases – namely, that there will not be any without sustainably higher inflation – must change before bond yields can have any hope of climbing higher. A Shift From Central Banks To Concerns About Asset Price Bubbles Chart 7When Will CBs Start Worrying About Financial Market Valuations? Policymakers are paying lip service to the notion of the “financial stability” risks inherent in their new promises to keep rates low for a lot longer while intervening in financial markets more aggressively through asset purchase programs. Given the signs of froth in many important asset classes like US equities or global corporate debt, policymakers should at least be somewhat concerned that easy money policies are fueling asset bubbles (Chart 7). A big enough decline could erode confidence and spill over into the real economy, defeating the original purpose of easy money policies. However, given the still fragile state of much of the global economy that remains dependent on fiscal support amid ongoing COVID-19 restrictions, concerns over asset values will take a backseat to maintaining adequate monetary stimulus. Asset bubbles would have to become much larger before a central bank would even consider turning more hawkish to prick them through higher policy rates that would push up bond yields. The Announcement Of A Trustworthy COVID-19 Vaccine That Is Ready For Widespread Distribution Markets have already begun to worry about the “second wave” of the coronavirus that health officials had warned would happen in the cooler autumn months. The development of an effective, and safe, vaccine would thus be a game-changer for financial markets, particularly after the recent surge in new COVID-19 cases in Europe and the still elevated level of new cases in the US (Chart 8). Chart 8A Second Wave Of COVID-19 BCA Research’s Chief Global Strategist, Peter Berezin (a big fan of interesting data sets!), noted in his most recent report that, according to The Good Judgement Project, around 60% of “superforecasters” now expect a vaccine ready for mass distribution to be available by Q1/2021 (Chart 9).1 A vaccine appearing that rapidly – much faster than the usual multi-year process leading to a vaccine declared safe for use – would help boost business and consumer confidence and raise the odds of a return to pre-virus levels of economic activity. Bond yields would likely get a lift, as well, as markets would price in a shorter period of super low policy rates and a faster return of inflation to central bank targets. Yet even if a vaccine is presented to the world by next spring, there is no guarantee that a large enough share of the population will deem the vaccine safe enough to take to ensure “herd immunity”. A recent Economist/YouGuv survey noted that only 36% of American adults would choose to get vaccinated when a COVID-19 vaccine becomes available, 32% would not get vaccinated, while 32% were unsure (Chart 10). Thus, a vaccine would be a bond-bearish development only if it is trusted to be safe to use – the mere announcement of a vaccine will not be enough to declare an “end” to the pandemic. Chart 9High Odds Of A Vaccine In 6-To-12 Months Chart 10Will Enough People Take The Vaccine? Central Banks Slowing QE Purchases Relative To Increased Fiscal Issuance Chart 11Still Room For The Fed, ECB and BoE To Expand QE Right now, it is easy for the major central banks to aggressively expand their balance sheets and provide additional monetary stimulus through asset purchases. Yet there may come a point where a capacity constraint is reached on buying government bonds if it impairs market functionality. That is currently the case in Japan, where the Bank of Japan now owns 49% of the Japanese government bond (JGB) market after years of aggressive QE purchases of JGBs. This has damaged the day-to-day liquidity of JGBs, where there have been instances of days where no single JGB has traded in the secondary market. A move by central banks to buy fewer bonds because they own too many of them could potentially push bond yields higher by worsening the demand/supply balance for government bonds - assuming private investors do not pick up the slack and buy more bonds, of course. Currently, the Fed only owns 22% of the US Treasury market with little evidence suggesting that its purchases are impairing the trading of Treasuries (Chart 11). The BoE and ECB own much larger shares of the UK and euro area government bond markets – 37% and 38%, respectively – suggesting that those central banks are closer to a BoJ-like capacity constraint. However, given the rising budget deficits and surging government bond issuance seen in Europe (and the US) so far in 2020, the odds of a capacity constraint soon being reached that could result in slower QE purchases are low. Bottom Line: Developed market bond yields have ignored improving cyclical economic data over the past few months, remaining stuck in narrow trading ranges at low levels. That broken correlation will persist until central banks become less concerned about supporting pandemic-ravaged economies and begin worrying more about rising inflation, financial stability or the size of their balance sheets. That shift will not happen anytime soon. Reviewing Our Tactical Inflation Breakeven Trades Back in June, we initiated a series of recommended inflation-focused trades in our Tactical Overlay portfolio. Specifically, we went long 10-year inflation breakevens in the US, Italy, and Canada by buying on-the-run inflation-linked bonds and selling government bond futures.2 We chose those trades based on the output of our fundamental valuation models for 10-year inflation breakevens in eight inflation-linked bond (ILB) markets: the US, UK, France, Italy, Japan, Germany, Canada, and Australia. Our fair value models use two inputs for all regions: a) a long-run moving average of headline inflation, representing the medium-term trend that anchors inflation expectations; and b) the annual percentage change of the Brent oil price in local currency terms, which creates shorter-term deviations from the trend to account for moves in oil and currencies. There looks to be little remaining upside to our tactical long TIPS breakeven position. The past few months have seen a sharp rise in global inflation expectations, owing to the extraordinary monetary policy actions taken by the major developed market central banks and recovering growth prospects coming out of the COVID-19 recession. This has led to a convergence between 10-year inflation breakevens and their model-implied fair values in the aforementioned ILB markets (Chart 12). Most notably, breakevens in the US are now at fair value, while breakevens in the UK and Australia are trading above fair value. In the US, 10-year breakeven inflation rates are now back to the long-run average of realized headline inflation, while the -8% decline in the Brent oil price so far this month has lowered the model-implied fair value (Chart 13). Therefore, there looks to be little remaining upside to our tactical long TIPS breakeven position with most of the easy gains following the pandemic-induced collapse having already been realized. Chart 12Global Inflation Breakevens Have Moved Higher Our colleagues over at BCA Research US Bond Strategy have reached a similar conclusion, noting that the Fed’s Jackson Hole announcement of the move to Average Inflation Targeting supercharged the rising trend in TIPS breakevens.3 Chart 13US Breakevens Are At Fair Value Although they also note the likelihood of stronger US CPI prints over the next few months should keep US breakevens well supported heading into year-end. The time horizon for trades that enter our Tactical Overlay portfolio is limited to no longer than six months. Thus, with TIPS breakevens reverting back to fair value after just three months in the trade, we are choosing to take profits on our long 10-year US inflation breakeven trade for a total return of 2.88%. Chart 14UK Breakevens Are Above Fair Value In other ILB markets, UK breakevens are now an intriguing case, and not only for the monetary policy driven interplay between UK real yields and breakevens discussed earlier in this report. The overshoot of UK breakevens relative to our fair value model may be related to growing market speculation that the BoE will move to negative interest rates – an outcome we deem to be unlikely, as we discussed in a recent report.4 Alternatively, the higher breakevens may be a reflection of UK political uncertainty. The risk of a hard Brexit has resurfaced as UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s Conservatives have now backed a bill that includes powers for the government to override its withdrawal agreement with the European Union; understandably, this has caused a sell-off in the pound. Within our fundamental fair value framework, the UK 10-year breakeven inflation rate has overshot both the 3-year moving average of headline inflation and the growth of GBP-denominated oil prices, leaving breakevens 0.72 standard deviations expensive (Chart 14). One possible explanation is that markets are pricing in a significant further depreciation in the pound given this resurfacing of Brexit risk. Within our model, GBP/USD impacts the fair value of breakeven inflation via Brent oil prices, which are denominated in local currency terms. Thus, we can back out an implied change in GBP/USD that would make the model-derived fair value breakeven rate equal to the actual 10-year UK inflation breakeven rate, holding all other variables in the model constant. This does produce some extreme results during periods of very rapid moves in UK breakevens, but we can standardize the data to use as an indicator of ILB market-implied views on the currency (Chart 15). With that in mind, pound bearishness in ILB markets is nearing levels where it has historically troughed. A favorable development in Brexit negotiations could cause a reversal in this pound-bearish trend and a sharp downward correction in UK inflation breakevens. We see a potential opportunity to play for narrower UK breakevens if our view on Brexit and negative rates in the UK prove to be correct. On that front, BCA Research’s Chief Geopolitical Strategist, Matt Gertken, sees a no-deal Brexit by year-end as the less likely outcome, with odds of only 35%, given the political calculus that PM Johnson faces with the decision.5 Polls show that the UK public does not support a no-deal Brexit (Chart 16), which would severely hurt a UK economy that remains fragile due to the coronavirus, and would raise the odds of a new independence referendum in Scotland in 2021. Chart 15UK Breakevens Already Discount A Big Fall In GBP Chart 16Only 25% In The UK Think A No-Deal Brexit Is A Good Outcome We will monitor the situation closely in the coming weeks, but we see a potential opportunity to play for narrower UK breakevens if our view on Brexit and negative rates in the UK prove to be correct. Finally, although the majority of the gains from our long inflation breakeven trades in Canada and Italy have likely been realized, there are still some chips left on the table. Canadian breakeven inflation rates have risen in lockstep with Brent prices but have yet to converge with the long-run moving average of inflation (Chart 17). In Italy, the increases in oil prices in euro terms has outstripped the rise in breakevens, pushing up the model-implied fair value and leaving breakevens remain more than one standard deviation under fair value (Chart 18). We will look for the gap between breakevens and fair values to shrink further in these two countries before closing these trades, even though we are substantially in the green on both (see the Tactical Overlay table on page 19). Chart 17Canadian Breakevens Are Just Below Fair Value Chart 18Italian Breakevens Are Well Below Fair Value Bottom Line: Our models suggest US TIPS breakevens are now at fair value. We are taking profit on our tactical long US 10-year inflation breakeven trade for a return of 2.88%. Stay long 10-year breakevens in Italy and Canada until we see further shrinkage in the gap between inflation breakevens and model-implied fair value and watch for a selling opportunity in UK 10-year breakevens. Robert Robis, CFA Chief Fixed Income Strategist rrobis@bcaresearch.com Shakti Sharma Research Associate ShaktiS@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see BCA Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Pivot To Value", dated September 18, 2020, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. You can also learn more about The Good Judgement Project here: https://goodjudgment.com/about/ 2 Please see BCA Research Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report, "How To Play The Revival Of Global Inflation Expectations", dated June 23, 2020, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see BCA Research US Bond Strategy Portfolio Allocation Summary, "The Fed’s New Framework Is Bond Bearish…But Not Yet", dated September 8, 2020, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com. 4 Please see BCA Research Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report, "Assessing The Leading Candidates To Join The Negative Rate Club", dated August 26, 2020, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com. 5 Please see BCA Research Geopolitical Strategy Weekly Report, "The End-Game For Trump And Brexit", dated September 18, 2020, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. Recommendations The GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. The Custom Benchmark Index Duration Regional Allocation Spread Product Tactical Trades Yields & Returns Global Bond Yields Historical Returns
As cheap as global value stocks are in comparison to growth stocks, their outperformance will not emerge out of a vacuum. Historically, the main catalyst for periods of outperformance of value stocks comes from stronger global economic activity. Strong…
Yesterday, the release of the September Flash PMIs in the euro area bore the imprint of the COVID-19 second wave. The Composite measure declined from 51.9 to 50.1, dragged down by a sharp fall in Services from 50.5 to 47.6. Interestingly, the Manufacturing…
Kenya: An Incomplete Adjustment The Kenyan shilling will depreciate by 15-20% in the next 12 months. The downward pressure on the currency stems from the country’s sizeable current account deficit. In addition, Kenya needs lower local interest rates and a weaker exchange rate to boost nominal growth and stabilize public debt dynamics. Kenya has gone through an extensive macro adjustment since 2015 when the current account deficit was 10% of GDP and the primary fiscal deficit was 8% of GDP. Since then the current account deficit has narrowed to 6% of GDP as the private sector deleveraged and fiscal policy tightened substantially over the past 3-years (Chart I-1, top panel). Remarkably, the primary fiscal deficit has narrowed to a mere 0.4% of GDP as of June 2020 (Chart I-1, bottom panel). Yet, the macro adjustment is incomplete with a lingering current account deficit and public debt on an unsustainable path. Further, economic growth is extremely weak (Chart I-2). Crucially, core inflation is at 2% - an all-time low, suggesting that low inflation/deflationary pressures is the main problem in Kenya (Chart I-3). Chart I-1Kenya: The Twin Deficits Remains Large Chart I-2Kenya: Tame Domestic Growth In this context, the optimal policy choice for Kenya is to reduce local interest rates, while allowing the currency to depreciate. This will reduce the interest burden on public debt, boost both economic activity (real growth) and inflation as well as make exports more competitive. Balance Of Payments Strains Persist Kenya’s balance of payments will weigh on the currency in the next 6-9 months. While improving, its exports will remain tame over the next 6-12 months. The volume of tea, horticulture and coffee exports, which account for about 50% of total Kenyan exports, has rebounded. Yet, their prices have failed to rebound meaningfully. Meanwhile, substantial fiscal tightening – an 11% drop in government non-interest nominal expenditures – has led to a collapse in imports (Chart I-4). If and when fiscal policy is relaxed, it will boost imports weighing on the trade balance. Chart I-3Kenya Suffers From Low Inflation Chart I-4Tight Fiscal Policy = Weak Domestic Demand Chart I-5Kenya Is Losing Market Share In Export Markets The biggest headwind to the balance of payments has been the drastic fall in both tourism revenues and remittances. Combined, they represent around $4 billion (4.2% of GDP). It is unlikely that international travel will resume in the next six months. Remittances will also remain subdued in the coming months as unemployment rates remain elevated worldwide. Kenya has been losing its export market share in neighboring countries such as Uganda and Tanzania (Chart I-5). Hence, this nation needs to improve its competitiveness via tolerating a cheaper currency and undertaking structural reforms to bolster productivity growth. FDI inflows have been subdued. In the near term, FDI inflows will be discouraged by very weak domestic demand. Critically, the outlook for Chinese FDI inflows into the country remains uncertain due to the debacle with previous China-financed projects in Kenya. In particular, Kenyan courts declared the construction contract awarded to the China Road and Bridge Corporation for the Nairobi-Mombasa railway illegal.1 This impasse between Kenyan courts and Chinese companies could for now dissuade financing and investment from China. In the medium term, international organizations such as the IMF and World Bank could step in to fill in for Chinese investments. As recent financing by the World Bank and IMF of $1.74 billion (1.9% of GDP) to Kenya suggest, the US might be enticed alongside European nations to step in to fill the vacuum left by the withdrawal of China’s financial backing. However, this might take some time and there will be shortage in foreign financing in the coming months. Chart I-6Kenya Lacks Foreign Exchange Reserves Finally, another risk is the considerable amount of foreign debt obligations (FDOs) and the lack of foreign currency reserves at the central bank to meet these obligations (Chart I-6). Kenya’s FDOs in the next 12 months are about $6 billion, while the central bank has only $8.8 billion of foreign exchange reserves. In this case, FDOs measure the sum of short-term claims, interest payments and amortization over the next 12 months. Bottom Line: The exchange rate will continue facing depreciation pressures. The optimal policy for the central bank will be to allow the currency to weaken meaningfully and to reduce interest rates rather than use high interest rates or deplete its foreign exchange reserves to defend the exchange rate. Public Debt Sustainability Despite substantial fiscal tightening, Kenya’s public debt trajectory remains worrisome. Two prerequisites for capping the rise in the public debt-to-GDP ratio are (1) running continuous primary fiscal surpluses and (2) for local government borrowing costs to be below nominal GDP growth. Neither of these two are presently satisfied in Kenya. Crucially, interest payments are taking up a quarter of overall government revenues (Chart I-7). This necessitates considerably lower domestic interest rates to reduce this ratio. In brief, public debt sustainability hinges on the central bank reducing local borrowing costs, which will both boost nominal growth/government revenues and lower interest costs of public debt. The government of President Uhuru Kenyatta announced a new budget in June (for the period of July 1, 2020 to June 30, 2021) with a projected primary deficit of -3% and -1.8% of GDP, for 2020/21 and 2021/22 respectively (Chart I-1, bottom panel on page 1). Meanwhile, the new budget’s nominal annual growth projections for 2020/21 and 2021/22 are 10.6% and 11.5%, respectively. Chart I-8presents both the government’s as well as our projections for public debt dynamics until the end of 2022 based on assumptions for nominal GDP, government expenditures and revenues for the next two fiscal years. The public debt-to-GDP ratio will reach 75% of GDP in our scenario and 66% in the government’s scenario. Chart I-7Public Debt Servicing Costs Are High Chart I-8Kenya: Public Debt Will Continue To Rise The key difference between the two projections are expectations for nominal GDP and government revenue growth. If fiscal and monetary policy remain tight, nominal output growth will disappoint. Notably, broad money supply growth is tame (Chart I-9). Sluggish nominal growth risks derailing government revenue projections. Notably, recent comments by finance minister Ukur Yatani suggests that revenues have already begun underperforming government expectations in the first two months of the new fiscal year. On the whole, public debt will rise by more than what the government expects over the next two years as borrowing costs remain above nominal GDP growth (Chart I-10). Chart I-9Kenya: Weak Policy Response To Low Growth Chart I-10Kenya: Local Rates Are Above Nominal Growth Faced with the prospect of rising public debt dynamics over the next two years, the economically less painful response for policymakers is for the central bank to lower interest rates and to instruct domestic commercial banks to buy government domestic debt. This will boost nominal GDP growth and push local interest rates below nominal GDP growth. There is scope for the central bank to cut interest rates and allow the currency to depreciate without feeding into runaway inflation. Notably, core consumer price inflation excluding fuel and food items is presently at an all-time low, running below the lower bound of the central bank’s inflation target (Chart I-2 on page 2). Higher inflation also feeds into higher nominal growth, which is good for public debt dynamics. A weaker currency will augment the cost of servicing foreign debt. The latter accounts for 52% of public debt and 32% of GDP. However, a large share (65%) of foreign debt is owed to bilateral and multilateral creditors. This debt can be renegotiated/restructured, which would in turn benefit private creditors. Bottom Line: To stabilize public debt dynamics, local interest rates should be lowered considerably. This will increase nominal GDP and government revenue growth as well as lower debt servicing costs. In this scenario, currency will depreciate a lot. Investment Implications Faced with very depressed economic growth, very low inflation, unsustainable public debt dynamics and a wide current account deficit, the optimal policy for Kenya is to ease monetary policy dramatically and tolerate material currency depreciation. So long as the central bank does not reduce interest rates, the economy will continue to underwhelm, public debt dynamics will be worrisome and share prices will stumble (Chart I-11). Critically, as the public debt-to-GDP ratio continues rising, sovereign credit will underperform (Chart I-12). Chart I-11Weak Domestic Dynamics = Lower Share Prices Chart I-12Rising Public Debt Burden = Sovereign Credit Underperformance If and when the central bank brings interest rates down substantially, nominal growth will improve and share prices will fare well. Lower domestic borrowing costs and higher nominal GDP growth will help stabilize public debt dynamics. In such a scenario, EM sovereign credit portfolios should overweight the nation’s US dollar bonds. The Kenyan shilling also is set to depreciate materially. If the government embarks on this macro adjustment early, currency depreciation could be gradual. If the government delays this macro adjustment and resists currency weakness by tolerating high interest rates, the exchange rate depreciation could be delayed, but will be abrupt and disorderly. Andrija Vesic Associate Editor andrijav@bcaresearch.com Arthur Budaghyan Chief Emerging Markets Strategist arthurb@bcaresearch.com Nigeria: Devaluation As The Least-Worst Policy Choice Chart II-1Nigeria: Poor BoP Position The Nigerian naira is facing a considerable risk of major devaluation stemming from strains on its balance of payments (BoP). That said, the risk of a sovereign default is very low over the next 12-18 months. Nigeria suffers from large external imbalances in an environment of low oil prices and dreadful FDI inflows. The nation’s current account deficit is wide at 5% of GDP and its foreign currency (FX) reserves are low (Chart II-1). Importantly, oil prices have hit a critical technical resistance – their 200-day moving average – and have relapsed (Chart II-2). Global oil demand weakness stemming from some renewed tightening of lockdown measures will result in lower crude prices. We at BCA’s Emerging Markets Strategy team expect Brent prices to be in a trading range of $35-$45 over the next 12 months.2 An Optimal Macro Adjustment A low oil price environment creates a dillemma for Nigeria’s policymakers given their limited FX reserves. They can either (i) draw down FX reserves to support the exchange rate, or (ii) preserve FX reserves and allow a major currency devaluation. So far, Nigerian authorities have avoided these options by resorting to strict capital controls and limiting imports. Yet, capital controls are derailing much needed foreign capital inflows in general and FDIs in particular. These capital account controls are also restricting the ability of domestic firms to access US dollars to service their foreign debt payments, undermining the confidence of foreign investors and multilateral creditors. Allowing currency depreciation is the least-worst macro policy solution. Propping up the currency by administrative restrictions amid low oil prices will foster various imbalances impeding the nation’s structural adjustments and its potential growth rate. Remarkably, Nigeria’s current account excluding oil has been structurally wide, a sign of weak domestic productivity and a non-competitive currency (Chart II-3). Chart II-2A Relapse In Oil Prices Is Likely Chart II-3Nigeria Has A Current Account Deficit Ex-Oil Bottom Line: Capital controls and import restrictions are impeding FDIs and productivity growth in this most populous African country (Chart II-4). While a steep devaluation will spur inflation in the short run, a cheapened currency and the abolishment of import and capital controls will help to attract foreign capital that the nation desperately needs. Running Out Of FX Reserves Critically, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) is running out of FX reserves: Nigeria’s foreign exchange (FX) reserves are very low at $35.6 billion. That compares with foreign debt obligations (FDOs) of $28 billion in the next 12 months and foreign funding requirements of $47 billion in the next 12 months (Chart II-5). Chart II-4Nigeria: Weak FDI = Low Productivity Chart II-5Nigeria: Large Foreign Funding Required In Next 12 Months FDOs measure the sum of short-term claims, interest payments and amortization over the next 12 months. Meanwhile, foreign funding requirements is the sum of the current account deficit and FDOs. FDI inflows were a mere $2.5 billion in 2019 compared with a $20 billion current account deficit. Along with foreign portfolio inflows, FDI inflows will remain depressed so long as capital controls persist. The FX reserves-to-broad money ratio currently stands at 0.4. A ratio below one indicates foreign currency reserves do not entirely cover currency in circulation and local currency deposits. How much should the exchange rate be devalued versus the US dollar for this ratio to reach 1? For the broad money supply coverage ratio to be equal to 1, the currency must depreciate by 56% against the US dollar. Bottom Line: CBN’s FX reserves are insufficient to maintain the current de-facto crawling currency peg in the long run. No Worries About Sovereign Credit For Now Chart II-6Nigeria: Low Public Debt Burden While the Nigerian government is reeling from lower oil prices, the likelihood of a sovereign default is presently low. Public debt is low, currently standing at 22.5% of GDP. Notably, foreign debt represents nearly 30% of overall public debt or 6.5% of GDP. Moreover, only 40% of external debt (3% of GDP) is owned to private foreign investors (Chart II-6). The rest is split between bilateral and multilateral creditors. Foreign bilateral and multilateral debt is easier to renegotiate. While overall (domestic and foreign) debt servicing costs have risen to 55% of government revenues, foreign currency debt servicing costs only represent 2% of overall revenues. Provided foreign public debt servicing is minimal, even a large currency depreciation will not make public debt dynamics unsustainable. Crucially, a substantial currency devaluation will ameliorate the fiscal position. A large share (about 55%) of fiscal revenues come from oil, i.e., they are in US dollars. Conversely, expenditures are in local currency terms. As a result, currency depreciation will boost revenues but not expenditures, narrowing the budget deficit. According to the newly revised budget for the 2020 fiscal year, fiscal spending will grow by 8.7% in nominal terms but most likely contract in real terms (Chart II-7). Overall, the fiscal balance will widen to 3.65% of GDP in 2020 according to government projections. In nutshell, policymakers refrained from large fiscal stimulus amid lockdown measures earlier this year. This is bad for the economy but positive for the trajectory of public debt. Finally, public debt dynamics are presently not worrisome with nominal GDP growth above local interest rates (Chart II-8). Chart II-7Nigeria Will Run Tight Fiscal Policy Chart II-8Nigeria: No Public Debt Sustainability Problem Bottom Line: The risk of a sovereign default is low in the coming years. The low starting points in both public debt levels and debt servicing costs will allow the government to boost fiscal spending to support the economy. Investment Implications Overall, a currency devaluation will help restore balance of payment dynamics without causing a major stress for sovereign credit. A 25-30% devaluation over the next 12 months will be the least-worst policy choice. Currency forwards are currently pricing a 20% depreciation in the naira versus the US dollar in next 12 months (Chart II-9). Yet, the average black market exchange rate, currently at around 470, implies almost a 25% discount from the current official rate. Sovereign credit spreads are presently tight (Chart II-10). Investors should consider buying Nigerian sovereign credit only after a substantial devaluation takes place. Chart II-9Naira Forwards Discount Will Widen With Lower Oil Prices Chart II-10Nigeria: Buy Sovereign Credit After Devaluation Finally, equity investors should continue avoiding the local bourse. Due to capital controls, the latter is uninvestable for now. Andrija Vesic Associate Editor andrijav@bcaresearch.com Arthur Budaghyan Chief Emerging Markets Strategist arthurb@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 The standard gauge railways project built between the port city of Mombasa and its capital Nairobi has been heavily scrutinized by Kenyan authorities. After only three years of operation, the Kenyan Railways Company (KRC) has already defaulted on its loan from Chinese lenders. Kenyan courts have been arguing that Kenyan government and state-owned enterprises are facing sovereign risk over Chinese debt overhang. More than half of Kenya’s loans from China are attached to the construction of the Mombasa-Nairobi railway project. 2 This differs from BCA Commodity and Energy Strategy service’s expectation that Brent prices will average $65 in 2021.
The liabilities of the Japanese nonfinancial corporate sector stand at an elevated 190% of GDP. Debt, specifically, stands at 104% of GDP. This debt load is more elevated than in Germany, the US or the UK (60% of GDP, 75% of GDP and 80% of GDP, respectively)…
Taiwanese export orders rose 13.6% annually in August, or the fastest pace in two and a half years. Orders for electronics products and information & communication products were both particularly strongly, rising 28.2% and 26.4%, respectively. The strength of…

